Why did Reuben sleep with his father's concubine, Bilhah

An extraordinary verse appears immediately after the death of Rachel, Jacob’s dearest wife, whilst giving birth to Benjamin.

And it came to pass, when Israel dwelt in the land, that Reuben went and lay with Bilhah his father’s concubine: and Israel heard it. Now the sons of Jacob were twelve (Gen. 35:22).

Three questions arise: (i) why are the different names Israel and Jacob usedeven though the two sentences are adjacent to each other? (ii) why did Reuben venture to sleep with Rachel’s maidservant, Bilhah? and (iii) why are we told ‘out of the blue’ that the sons of Jacob are twelve?

After Reuben sleeps with Bilhah, the Bible states ‘And Israel heard it” and immediately afterwards it states: “Now the sons of Jacob were twelve”. For this act Reuben, the first born, is chastised by Israel not only in this instance, but also in his blessing of Reuben at the time of Jacob’s death.

Reuben thou art my firstborn, my might and the beginning of my strength, the excellency of dignity, and the excellency of power: Unstable as water, thou shalt not excel, because thou wentest up to thy father’s bed and then defilest thou it; he went up to my couch (Gen. 49:3-4).

Reuben lost favor with his father ever since even until his death, so why did he do it? As we have seen previously, Reuben, as the firstborn, was always very concerned about the fertility of his parents and the number of his brothers. In the incident of the mandrakes it is Reuben who delivers the mandrakes to his mother Leah after the birth of Asher, the 8th child. It is Reuben who sees that his mother has stopped becoming pregnant. He knows that Rachel is barren and so he tries to induce pregnancy of his mother by using mandrakes. Later in the story the mandrakes get passed on to Rachel, giving rise to the birth of Joseph (Chapter 8). 

Reuben understood that there should be thirteen sons of Jacob, - and therefore 13 tribes of Israel - and not twelve, and that the 13th son should be from Rachel’s womb, or at least from her maidservant’s, which would count as the same thing[1]. So, after the death of Rachel he takes Rachel’s maidservant, Bilhah, and sleeps with her, hoping to increase the number of the tribes of Israel to 13. Hence, the sentence: “Now the sons of Jacob were twelve”.  This ploy was not successful, and Bilhah does not become pregnant.

Later, we again see Reuben’s concern over the number of brothers and tribes of Israel. When his brothers intend to slay Joseph, it is Reuben who desperately tries to save him that he might deliver him to his father again.

And Reuben heard it, and he saved him from their hands; and said, Let us not kill him: And Reuben said to them, Shed no blood, but throw him into this pit that is in the wilderness, and lay no hand upon him; that he might rid him from their hands, to deliver him to his father again (Gen. 37:21-22).

Reuben’s concern and despair is further realized when he returns to the pit into which Joseph was thrown and finds him gone, for if Joseph is slain there would only be 11 sons.

And Reuben returned to the pit; and, behold, Joseph was not in the pit; and he tore his clothes (Gen.37:21-22).

However, it is God who decides how and when there should be thirteen tribes of Israel, as indeed He does through the birth of Ephraim and Manasseh, the sons of Joseph, who indirectly come through Rachel’s womb. Jacob very explicitly incorporated Ephraim and Manasseh into the tribes of Israel when he blessed them on his deathbed, saying: 

And now your two sons, Ephraim and Manasseh, who were born to you in the land of Egypt before I came to you to Egypt, are mine; as Reuben and Simeon, they shall be mine: And your issue, born to you after them, shall be yours, and shall be called after the name of their brothers in their inheritance (Gen. 48:5-6)

In thee shall Israel bless, saying God make these as Ephraim and Manasseh (Gen. 48:20). 

Here again we see that when Reuben sleeps with Bilhah and in the blessing of Ephraim and Manasseh, the name ‘Israel’ is used instead of Jacob. Moreover, Jacob states very clearly that any sons born after Ephraim and Manasseh shall not be numbered as Jacob’s offspring, but shall be Joseph’s.

The tribes of Israel can best be described in the diagram below, where Joseph fits the blessing of Jacob, saying:

Joseph is a fruitful bough, a fruitful bough by a well; whose branches run over the wall (Gen. 49:22).

The very structure of the diagram shows that the two sons of Joseph are indeed like a fruitful bough whose branches run over the wall. What does it mean? The tribes of Israel are like a tree that continues to develop, evolve, change, learn, invent, explore into the unknown over the wall and go through continual renewal.

Moreover, 13 is the gematrical value of the letter of the word ‘one’ achad, אחד , showing that the thirteen tribes possess unity within their diversity. Thirteen is half the value of the components of the letter aleph א, and of the tetragrammaton YHVH both of which have a value of 26; thirteen denotes the qualities of God and, not least, 13 is the gematrical value for love, (see Chapter 1).The unity of the thirteen tribes of Israel on earth is complemented by the unity of God in Heaven and that unity is the unity of LOVE. 

Twelve is a static number; there is no growth, evolution or development. It is confined and limited; it has no movement or change. Twelve is the measure of the phenomenal world, whereas thirteen is the measure of unity. Twelve is for the tribes Ishmael:

And as for Ishmael, I have heard you; Behold, I have blessed him, and will make him fruitful, and will multiply him exceedingly; twelve princes shall he father, and I will make him a great nation (Gen. 17:20).

The 13 Tribes of Israel

[1] According to Nuzi tablets in the Mesopotamia region, it was common for a wife to give her maidservant to her husband should she be barren; a child of a maidservant would be treated as a child of the wife.

The Mandrake Incident

In the procession of births of the sons of Jacob indicated in Genesis 29 and 30, we come across an extraordinary interlude in which Reuben brings mandrakes for his mother, Leah; Rachel then barters with Leah, offering her husband Jacob for that night in exchange for the mandrakes (Gen. 30:13-16).

This is the first of three instances where Reuben, the first-born, demonstrates his concern about the fertility of his father’s wives and concubines, or rather, about the number of tribes of Israel that are born. (See https://thealeph.leonvdk.com/uncategorized/why-did-reuben-sleep-with-his-fathers-concubine-bilhah/). Why did Reuben take it upon himself to bring mandrakes to his mother and why is ‘the mandrake incident’ mentioned in the middle of the sequence of births formulating the tribes of the Children of Israel? We suspect that this incident signals that something special is going to happen. The mandrake incident occurs after the birth of Asher, who is the 8th son and born during the wheat harvest.

The mandrake is a very powerful plant. It is said that the root has human shape and anyone who uproots the mandrake from the ground will die. Ancient lore has it that the mandrake fell into Reuben’s hands via his donkey which, struggling to get free of the bush he was tied to, uprooted the mandrake and consequently died.

The mandrake brings male and female together through the aroma it produces. In the love songs of Solomon it reads: The mandrakes give aroma, and at our gates are all manner of pleasant fruits, new and old, which I have laid up for thee, O my beloved (Songs of Songs 7:14) [1]. It is for this reason that the verse Lecha Dodi ‘Come my beloved’ in the Song of Songs, is sung during the Friday evening service to welcome in the Sabbath and is likened to welcoming a bride, or heaven coming to earth on the Sabbath eve.

The Hebrew word for mandrake is dodeim דודאים spelled: daled-vav-daled-aleph-yod-mem with a gematrical value of 4+6+4+1+10+40=65. Sixty-five is 5 x 13 where 5 is the number of the Crystal of Creation and 13 is the gematrical value for LOVE אהבה spelled aleph-heh-beth-heh = 1+5+2+5=13.

The word for mandrake is derived from the root word, dod, דוד spelled daled-vav-daled with a gematrical value of 4+6+4=14. Dod means both ‘uncle’ and ‘beloved’ and is also the spelling for the name ‘David.’[2] [3] As we know, the vav symbolizes a hook. Just as the letter aleph comprises two yods connected by a vav on either side representing the binding of God in Heaven and God on Earth, (see Chapter 1), soin this case the vav is binding the two daleds on either side, meaning the binding of male and female in the phenomenal world, represented by the number 4. This force that binds the two together is the force of love. It is for this reason that the Song of Songs is read during the Sabbath evening service, and the welcoming of the Sabbath is likened to the welcoming of a bride, binding Heaven and Earth and male and female forces together.

Similarly, considering dod as the Hebrew word for uncle, if we examine the family tree of the three patriarchs we see that they were in fact uncles to their wives [4] and that the union of male and female was indeed ‘the beloved’. The union of the three patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob to their wives Sarah, Rebecca, Rachel and Leah was a union of love. The birth of the Hebrew race was founded on LOVE.

Abraham, Isaac and Jacob were uncles to their wives


[1] The word ‘my beloved’, dodi and ‘mandrake’ dodeim, are from the same word root.

[2] In Hebrew, the vav ו can either be pronounced as an ‘o’ or ‘oo’ sound or as a ‘v’ sound.

[3] It is for this reason there are 14 Stations of the Cross along the Via Dolorosa in Jerusalem because it is interpreted from Isaiah 11:1 that the Messiah will be a descendent of King David.

[4] For this reason, both Abraham and Isaac escape perjury when allowing their wives to become concubines to Abimelech, claiming that they were their sisters, which was a common reference relating not only to an actual sister but also to close relatives (Gen. 20:9; 26:8).